Alexander S. de Witt

Alexander S. de Witt

Overview

Alex is a member of Butler Snow’s Tort, Transportation and Specialized Litigation group.

About

Alex serves as trial and appellate counsel in civil cases pending in federal and state courts, representing individuals, professionals, businesses and firms.  His areas of focus include insurance coverage litigation, insurance defense, flood litigation (National Flood Insurance Program), extra-contractual insurance claims, arson and insurance fraud, personal injury defense, general tort litigation, construction litigation, products liability, premises liability, business disputes, consumer law and complex commercial and class action litigation. 

Alex has extensive experience advising and representing insurance companies, agents and brokers in a variety of insurance cases, including commercial property and casualty, general liability insurance, homeowners insurance, flood insurance, motor vehicle liability insurance, uninsured and underinsured motorist insurance, medical expense benefits coverage, arson and fraud investigations, insurance coverage disputes, bad faith litigation, and negligence and malpractice claims against insurance professionals, agents and brokers.

Experience

  • Obtained a jury verdict of zero for defendant in personal injury negligence suit filed in the Eastern District of Virginia, in a case of admitted liability where the plaintiff (who had a pre-existing medical history) claimed injuries to her shoulder and lumbar spine and associated medical treatment (including two surgeries) following a rear-end car crash.
  • Secured dismissal of federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) claim filed against automobile insurance carrier in the Eastern District of Virginia, due to the absence of a sufficient injury-in-fact from the alleged FCRA violation under Spokeo, Inc. v. Robins, 578 U.S. 330 (2016) and its progeny.   
  • Secured summary judgment for flood insurance carrier in action filed in the Southern District of Texas which alleged breach of a federal Standard Flood Insurance Policy.
  • Represented flood claim adjusting company (appellee) in the Sixth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, which affirmed the District Court’s dismissal of all claims alleged against adjusting company on federal preemption grounds.
  • Represented flood insurance carrier (appellee) in Fifth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, which affirmed the District Court’s award of summary judgment to carrier.  
  • Represented flood insurance carrier and adjusting company (appellees) in the Fourth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, which affirmed the District Court’s dismissal of civil RICO claims.
  • Represented amicus curiae in support of commercial auto carrier (appellee) in the Fourth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, which affirmed the District Court’s award of summary judgment to carrier in uninsured motorist coverage dispute.
  • Represented auto insurance carrier (appellant) in the Fourth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, which reversed the District Court’s award of summary judgment against carrier in insurance coverage dispute.
  • Secured dismissal of all claims alleged against flood insurance carrier in action filed in the Middle District of Louisiana, based on federal preemption.
  • Secured dismissal of breach of contract and bad faith claims alleged against homeowners insurance carrier in action fi led in the Eastern District of Virginia.
  • Secured dismissal of claims alleged against insurance broker in the Western District of Virginia, in case alleging broker failed to procure adequate insurance for policyholder.
  • Successfully defended insurance agent sued for negligence, breach of fiduciary duty and breach of contract in a Virginia circuit court, for allegedly failing to procure sufficient property insurance coverage for apartment complex; settled favorably at mediation prior to Court’s ruling on agent’s dispositive motions.
  • Secured summary judgment for homeowners insurance carrier in declaratory judgment action filed in the Eastern District of Virginia, which determined that carrier had no duty under terms of insurance policy to provide liability coverage for claims alleged in underlying tort action.
  • Secured summary judgment for automobile insurance carrier sued for breach of contract and alleged bad faith denial of medical expense benefits coverage in Virginia circuit court.
  • Secured summary judgment for business liability carrier sued for breach of contract and alleged bad faith refusal to provide business liability coverage in Virginia circuit court.
  • Successfully defended homeowners insurance carrier against toxic mold claims in Eastern District of Virginia; settled favorably after Court announced that carrier was entitled to summary judgment.
  • Secured dismissal of tort and contract claims alleged against mortgage lender sued in Virginia state court for damages arising out of foreclosure sale of residential property; defended subsequent appeal to the Supreme Court of Virginia, which refused the petition for appeal.
  • Defense of putative class action filed in Eastern District of Virginia, alleging claims of discrimination under the federal Fair Housing Act, and under Virginia’s Fair Housing Law, Manufactured Home Lot Rental Act, and Residential Landlord and Tenant Act.
  • Defense of putative class action filed in federal court (D.D.C.), alleging claims of discrimination under the federal Equal Credit Opportunity Act, Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Virginia Consumer Protection Act, as well as state law fraud and contract claims.

Distinctions

  • Martindale-Hubbell®
    • AV® – Preeminent™ Peer Review Rated
  • Super Lawyers®
    • Virginia Rising Stars, 2011-2013

Bar Admissions

  • Virginia, 1998
  • U.S. District Courts
    • Virginia: Eastern, Western
    • Texas: Eastern, Southern
  • U.S. Court of Appeals
    • 4th Circuit
    • 5th Circuit
    • 6th Circuit

Education

  • George Mason University School of Law, J.D., 1998
  • University of Virginia, B.A., 1995

Associations

  • Virginia State Bar
    • Third District Disciplinary Committee, Section II, 2013-2019
      • Chair, 2015-2016
  • Virginia Association of Defense Attorneys
    • Policy Coverage Section
      • Chair, 2018-2019
      • Vice Chair, 2017-2018
    • Legislative Committee
      • Chair, 2020-2022
  • Richmond Bar Association
  • Henrico Bar Association
  • Virginia Bar Association
  • Federal Bar Association

Papers, Presentations & Publications

  • Co-Author, "Navigating Rough Waters: A Pre-Litigation Compass," 2024 Litigation Update: Navigating Emerging Trends and Technology, March 2024.
  • Co-Author, "Fire Insurance," Chapter 13 of Insurance Law in Virginia, Virginia CLE Publications, 4th ed., 2020.
  • Presenter, “Preservation and Spoliation of Evidence in Fire Investigations under NFPA 921 and Virginia Law,” Office of the Fairfax County Fire Marshal, September 6, 2018.
  • Co-Author, “Insurance Bad Faith Law In Virginia: What It Is And What It Isn’t,” The Journal of Civil Litigation, Virginia Association of Defense Attorneys, Summer 2019.
  • Author, "Expert Discovery Revisited: Amended Rule 26 in Action," Side Bar, Federal Litigation Section of the Federal Bar Association, Spring 2011.
  • Author, "Bankruptcy and Divorce: Dischargeability of Support and Property-Related Obligations," 50 Virginia Lawyer 12, Virginia State Bar, February 2001.
  • Author, "Classification, Valuation and Division of Stock Options," 2002 Family Law Update, Aspen Law & Business 2001.
  • Co-Author, "Enforcement and Contempt Proceedings," Virginia State Bar/Virginia CLE 20th Annual Family Law Seminar, October 2001.

Civic Involvement

  • Volunteer, Central Virginia Legal Aid Society/Virginia Bar Association Pro Bono Hotline, 2002-Present

Alexander S. de Witt

Overview

Alex is a member of Butler Snow’s Tort, Transportation and Specialized Litigation group.

About

Alex serves as trial and appellate counsel in civil cases pending in federal and state courts, representing individuals, professionals, businesses and firms.  His areas of focus include insurance coverage litigation, insurance defense, flood litigation (National Flood Insurance Program), extra-contractual insurance claims, arson and insurance fraud, personal injury defense, general tort litigation, construction litigation, products liability, premises liability, business disputes, consumer law and complex commercial and class action litigation. 

Alex has extensive experience advising and representing insurance companies, agents and brokers in a variety of insurance cases, including commercial property and casualty, general liability insurance, homeowners insurance, flood insurance, motor vehicle liability insurance, uninsured and underinsured motorist insurance, medical expense benefits coverage, arson and fraud investigations, insurance coverage disputes, bad faith litigation, and negligence and malpractice claims against insurance professionals, agents and brokers.

Experience

  • Obtained a jury verdict of zero for defendant in personal injury negligence suit filed in the Eastern District of Virginia, in a case of admitted liability where the plaintiff (who had a pre-existing medical history) claimed injuries to her shoulder and lumbar spine and associated medical treatment (including two surgeries) following a rear-end car crash.
  • Secured dismissal of federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) claim filed against automobile insurance carrier in the Eastern District of Virginia, due to the absence of a sufficient injury-in-fact from the alleged FCRA violation under Spokeo, Inc. v. Robins, 578 U.S. 330 (2016) and its progeny.   
  • Secured summary judgment for flood insurance carrier in action filed in the Southern District of Texas which alleged breach of a federal Standard Flood Insurance Policy.
  • Represented flood claim adjusting company (appellee) in the Sixth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, which affirmed the District Court’s dismissal of all claims alleged against adjusting company on federal preemption grounds.
  • Represented flood insurance carrier (appellee) in Fifth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, which affirmed the District Court’s award of summary judgment to carrier.  
  • Represented flood insurance carrier and adjusting company (appellees) in the Fourth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, which affirmed the District Court’s dismissal of civil RICO claims.
  • Represented amicus curiae in support of commercial auto carrier (appellee) in the Fourth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, which affirmed the District Court’s award of summary judgment to carrier in uninsured motorist coverage dispute.
  • Represented auto insurance carrier (appellant) in the Fourth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, which reversed the District Court’s award of summary judgment against carrier in insurance coverage dispute.
  • Secured dismissal of all claims alleged against flood insurance carrier in action filed in the Middle District of Louisiana, based on federal preemption.
  • Secured dismissal of breach of contract and bad faith claims alleged against homeowners insurance carrier in action fi led in the Eastern District of Virginia.
  • Secured dismissal of claims alleged against insurance broker in the Western District of Virginia, in case alleging broker failed to procure adequate insurance for policyholder.
  • Successfully defended insurance agent sued for negligence, breach of fiduciary duty and breach of contract in a Virginia circuit court, for allegedly failing to procure sufficient property insurance coverage for apartment complex; settled favorably at mediation prior to Court’s ruling on agent’s dispositive motions.
  • Secured summary judgment for homeowners insurance carrier in declaratory judgment action filed in the Eastern District of Virginia, which determined that carrier had no duty under terms of insurance policy to provide liability coverage for claims alleged in underlying tort action.
  • Secured summary judgment for automobile insurance carrier sued for breach of contract and alleged bad faith denial of medical expense benefits coverage in Virginia circuit court.
  • Secured summary judgment for business liability carrier sued for breach of contract and alleged bad faith refusal to provide business liability coverage in Virginia circuit court.
  • Successfully defended homeowners insurance carrier against toxic mold claims in Eastern District of Virginia; settled favorably after Court announced that carrier was entitled to summary judgment.
  • Secured dismissal of tort and contract claims alleged against mortgage lender sued in Virginia state court for damages arising out of foreclosure sale of residential property; defended subsequent appeal to the Supreme Court of Virginia, which refused the petition for appeal.
  • Defense of putative class action filed in Eastern District of Virginia, alleging claims of discrimination under the federal Fair Housing Act, and under Virginia’s Fair Housing Law, Manufactured Home Lot Rental Act, and Residential Landlord and Tenant Act.
  • Defense of putative class action filed in federal court (D.D.C.), alleging claims of discrimination under the federal Equal Credit Opportunity Act, Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Virginia Consumer Protection Act, as well as state law fraud and contract claims.

Distinctions

  • Martindale-Hubbell®
    • AV® – Preeminent™ Peer Review Rated
  • Super Lawyers®
    • Virginia Rising Stars, 2011-2013

Bar Admissions

  • Virginia, 1998
  • U.S. District Courts
    • Virginia: Eastern, Western
    • Texas: Eastern, Southern
  • U.S. Court of Appeals
    • 4th Circuit
    • 5th Circuit
    • 6th Circuit

Education

  • George Mason University School of Law, J.D., 1998
  • University of Virginia, B.A., 1995

Associations

  • Virginia State Bar
    • Third District Disciplinary Committee, Section II, 2013-2019
      • Chair, 2015-2016
  • Virginia Association of Defense Attorneys
    • Policy Coverage Section
      • Chair, 2018-2019
      • Vice Chair, 2017-2018
    • Legislative Committee
      • Chair, 2020-2022
  • Richmond Bar Association
  • Henrico Bar Association
  • Virginia Bar Association
  • Federal Bar Association

Papers, Presentations & Publications

  • Co-Author, "Navigating Rough Waters: A Pre-Litigation Compass," 2024 Litigation Update: Navigating Emerging Trends and Technology, March 2024.
  • Co-Author, "Fire Insurance," Chapter 13 of Insurance Law in Virginia, Virginia CLE Publications, 4th ed., 2020.
  • Presenter, “Preservation and Spoliation of Evidence in Fire Investigations under NFPA 921 and Virginia Law,” Office of the Fairfax County Fire Marshal, September 6, 2018.
  • Co-Author, “Insurance Bad Faith Law In Virginia: What It Is And What It Isn’t,” The Journal of Civil Litigation, Virginia Association of Defense Attorneys, Summer 2019.
  • Author, "Expert Discovery Revisited: Amended Rule 26 in Action," Side Bar, Federal Litigation Section of the Federal Bar Association, Spring 2011.
  • Author, "Bankruptcy and Divorce: Dischargeability of Support and Property-Related Obligations," 50 Virginia Lawyer 12, Virginia State Bar, February 2001.
  • Author, "Classification, Valuation and Division of Stock Options," 2002 Family Law Update, Aspen Law & Business 2001.
  • Co-Author, "Enforcement and Contempt Proceedings," Virginia State Bar/Virginia CLE 20th Annual Family Law Seminar, October 2001.

Civic Involvement

  • Volunteer, Central Virginia Legal Aid Society/Virginia Bar Association Pro Bono Hotline, 2002-Present